Climate Rally : 4th November 2006 : George Monbiot Transcript

Hello to all of you dangerous radical Climate Change activists !

I've done a little transcript of what George Monbiot and Richard Chartres had to say at the Climate Rally on 4th November 2006 in Grosvenor Square under the brooding shadow of the United States Embassy.

I am seeking corrections - but in the mean time : ENJOY !

==============================================================================
==============================================================================

Climate March : Rally 4th November 2006 : 12 midday

Transcript from the following two Internet Videos :-
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KXxkB-9Du-U
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ben7_7ORqzg

==============================================================================

[The Right Reverend Richard Chartres, Bishop of London speaks]

It's great to see you. I've just come with a whole lot of friends. Hundreds of them.

We've been meeting just in the church down the road.

And we've had a CUT THE CARBON service. Because that's something we're all agreed on.

Let's not mix the messages here - the big thing that needs to change is to CUT THE CARBON.

And we had a message. We had a message from the Bishop of Bangladesh.

Because one thing the Stern Report does - it takes away the fig leaf.

Climate Change is not only real : the impact is going to be first and foremost on the poor and
vulnerable of the World.

And he wrote on behalf of his children, from Bangladesh, saying that he feared - especially for his
grandchildren - that there would not be land on which they could stand.

And he's pleading with us - this is a message from Bangladesh which we received this morning -
to take this issue really seriously.

Because it's going to have an impact on the poorest and the most vulnerable in the whole World.

There are human beings in this World of ours who do not recognise that they are participants in
a web of life.

Who do not recognise that they are responsible : responsible to God, responsible to the Creation,
responsible to neighbours, responsible to their own well-being.

There are people so deluded as believe that they are gods, and that they have the right to tyrannise
over this Earth, and not to act as its stewards and its shepherds and its keepers.

So, avoid the God Delusion. Happiness doesn't come with Accumulation.

And above all the action, we must all take NOW is : CUT THE CARBON.

That's what Operation Noah says : CUT THE CARBON.

Thank you.

================================================================================

[Writer, journalist and activist George Monbiot speaks]

The denial of Climate Change has gone through four stages.

At first these people sponsored by Exxon - and curiously as we now discover - by the tobacco
company Philip Morris - told us that it wasn't taking place.

It was a fraud, a scam, cooked up by an anti-business, anti-American conspiracy.

Then they admitted that, OK, Climate Change IS happening. But it's a good thing, not a bad thing.
We can grow grapes in Yorkshire and have Mediterranean holidays in Southend.

Then they admitted : OK, Climate Change is happening and it's a bad thing.

But they said it would cost more to do anything about it than it would cost to live with.

Well, that argument has now been blown out of the water [by the Stern Report].

But it is not the final argument.

Instantly they've switched over to Denial Number 4 : which was that : OK, Climate Change is
happening. It's a bad thing, not a good thing. It would cost more to try to live with it that it would
cost to try to deal with it - but it's those damn Chinese who are causing the problem !

And we have here, ladies and gentlemen, yet another manifestation of the "Yellow Peril" :
these Chinese will [fix ?] the Planet. They will destroy everything that we are trying to do.

Forgetting perhaps that while the average emission of Carbon Dioxide in the United Kingdom is
9.5 tonnes per person per year : in China it is 2.7.

Forgetting perhaps that in China there are at least as many efforts towards Renewable Energy and other
carbon-saving technologies as there are here.

But, it's true : that at the moment, every nation is using every other nation as its excuse for inaction.

Everyone is pointing to everyone else to say : it can't be done because of that lot. And that lot are
pointing to us and saying it can't be done because of that lot.

But let me tell you, there are people like me talking to people like you in every country which we are
currently using as our excuse.

And in every country around the world, there are people saying : if only we can mobilise together,
as a Planet, we can defeat runaway Climate Change.

But the deniers of Climate Change are not finished yet.

And it is my prediction, I think not a very hard prediction to make, that they are about to move over to
Stage Five of Denial.

And this is to say : OK, Climate Change is happening; it's a bad thing not a good thing; it would
cost more to try to live with it than to do something about it, and it's not just those damn Chinese.

But : it is now too late.

That is what they're going to throw at us next.

And that, potentially, is the most devastating argument of all.

Now let me tell you that this argument has been pressaged - the argument that the Exxon-sponsored
deniers will use - by some among us.

And I've been astonished and horrified to see how among many of the people I have met as I've been
around the country over the past few weeks have switched, smoothly, from one position to another.

First they were saying, "Well it's not such a big deal. Do we really have to do anything about it ?"

And without any transitional stage in between, they have gone over to saying, "It's too late. We can't do
anything about it."

And in both cases we see a complete [abdication] of the moral responsibility to take action to prevent
runaway Climate Change.

And any environmentalist who collaborates in this project of trying to persuade us that it is now too late,
whatever his or her intention might have been, are, de facto, collaborating with the great and final argument
of the Climate Change deniers.

Our task is to demonstrate that it is not too late.

Now, I believe that I have shown through technological and economic measures how this extraordinary
target, [this] necessary target of a 90% cut by 2030, can be achieved.

But I have not demonstrated how it [could] be done politically.

And the reason that I have not done so is because it is not up to me to demonstrate that, it is up to you.

It is up to you to demonstrate it, not through argument and discussion and debate - the time for that is now
over.

We know that Climate Change is happening. We know it will be devastating. We know that runaway
Climate Change has to be stopped.

You must demonstrate this through action, and action alone.

The moral responsiblity of everyone who is standing here now is to show that it is not too late,
by forcing those who govern us to take the action which will ensure that it is not too late.

And you do that by mobilisation, mobilisation and mobilisation.

It starts today, but it does not end today. It carries on every day of this year, every day of next year,
every day of the next 24 years between now and 2030 until we have achieved that 90% cut
and introduced a high chance of preventing runaway Climate Change.

I'm not asking you to give up your job, or your family life, or many of the other things that are important
to you. But I am asking you to give up watching TV [television].

I am asking you to spend the time (well, there are several good reasons for asking it), so I'm asking you
to spend that time making Climate Change the top political priority : not for the Labour Party or the
Conservative Party, or the Lib Dems [Liberal Democrats] or the Greens : for all of those parties, and for
everybody in and out of party politics.

To put it right at the top of everybody's agenda and to create an atmosphere in this country that says
we do not stop, we do not stop until that 90% cut has been achieved.

And anyone who stands in the way of that cut, stands in the way of the last great hope for humanity.

That last great hope, ladies and gentlemen, is standing in front of me.

Thank you very much.

==============================================================================
==============================================================================